Performance analysis of urban drainage in Dhangadhi: a comparing study of traditional Excel Design and Hykas Simulation.
Student: Bikas Paudyal
Supervisor: Ganesh Parajuli
Submitted Date:
August, 2026
Abstract
Dhangadhi, a rapidly growing city in Nepal's Terai region, has faced chronic urban
flooding due to its flat terrain and expanding impervious surfaces. To address this, the
Asian Development Bank funded Regional Urban Development (RUDP) constructed
stormwater drains using traditional, Excel based hydraulic design (Rational Method and
Manning's Equation). However, no study had verified whether these drains actually
reduced flooding, or whether the traditional design method itself gave a reliable, cost-
effective picture of the network's true capacity.
This study addressed that gap through three objectives: to assess the flood-mitigation
impact of the RUDP drainage by comparing conditions before and after construction; to
compare the accuracy of the Excel based design against HYKAS hydrodynamic
simulation under steady and unsteady flow; and to identify the remaining operational
challenges and propose improvements. An applied, comparative case-study design was
used, combining primary and secondary data. A structured questionnaire was administered
to 100 households across Wards 1, 4, 5 and 8, selected through stratified sampling, and
analyzed using frequency distribution, chi-square tests and correlation analysis. In parallel,
the RUDP's design data and 30 years (1987-2016) of rainfall records were used to model
ten drainage sub-networks in HYKAS, comparing the conventional design against both
steady-state and unsteady-state (full Saint-Venant) simulations.
Results showed the RUDP drainage achieved significant flood reduction (81.2% to 12%
frequent flooding, p<0.001) and revealed that traditional methods over-designed the
network by 52% on average compared to realistic unsteady-state simulation, meaning
existing drains have substantial spare capacity; the main problems remaining are
operational—drain clogging and access constraints—not structural. The study concludes
that HYKAS hydrodynamic simulation offers a more accurate and cost-effective basis
than traditional spreadsheet methods for designing resilient urban drainage in similar
flood-prone cities.
Keywords
Urban Drainage System, Performance Evaluation, Hydrodynamic Modeling, HYKAS, Steady-State vs. Unsteady-State, Flood Mitigation, Infrastructure Over-Design, Saint-Venant Equations, Terai Region.